Onderwerp bekijken
 Onderwerp afdrukken
Meerdere SIP endpoints (b.v. Zyxel, Grandstream)
Sorry, omdat ik in het engels doorgaan moet, maar mijn nederlands is helaas nog steds niet goed genoeg voor zulke dingen....


I am trying to somehow get both, a phone connected to my Telfort ADSL modem (Zyxel with WiFi), and another SIP phone (Grandstream) working in parallel - so far without success :-(

As far as my knowledge of the SIP standard goes (IETF RFC3261), it is possible for multiple SIP endpoints to register at the same time.
It should therefore in principle be possible to activate both, the SIP stack inside the Zyxel modem which serves the telephone ports, AND a seperate SIP telephone to initiate/receive telephone calls.
The SIP registrar/proxy server would then "fork" any incoming calls to both receiving contact addresses, sequentially or in parallel, causing either both telephones to ring sequentially or one after the other.

As I said, so far I have not been able to register the second device, ie the SIP phone. Strangely, I have not been able to even activate this device as the only device, i.e. with the Zyxel phone service de-activated and all respective ports being forwarded. Although this might indicate that there is a problem with the telephone itself, this is definetely not the case, since the phone supports multiple SIP providers at the same time, and is successfully registered/using another SIP provider. Still, I would also like to provision a Telfort account in the SIP phone, so I can make local calls using my Telfort phone subscription.

Has someone made similar experiences or experimented successfully with a seperate or an additional SIP phone? Any ideas why I cannot register with the Grandstream despite using the exact same settings also used by the Zyxel in successfully registering to the network are very much appreciated.

Thanks & Regards
I haven't actually experimented with multiple SIP devices, but I do think that the problem here is: portmapping.

Your modem acts as a SIP device, therefore it will claim such traffic for its own SIP account(s), leaving your secundary SIP device unemployed.

How you can resolve this I'm not quite sure, I would suspect that you need to have the Grandstream operate at a different set of ports and make the appropriate portmappings, if at all possible.

Here's another thought though: the ZyXEL is perfectly capable of registering 2 different SIP accounts simultaneously, so why not do that and have 2 regulare phones connected to both phone ports?
Het is beter een kaars te ontsteken dan de duisternis te vervloeken.
I also thinking the problem lies in portmapping. Fact is that your sip ports on the modem are not present behind the nat filter and firewall but before it, if all is ok.

I don't know which Grandstream you have, they are great phones, but most models that I know personally are connected to the network by UTP (RJ45) and not by telephone jack (RJ11) on a voip port.
As far as I know this also means you can not connect your Grandstream to the voip port of a Zyxel modem.

That also means that your Grandstream is operating on the network behind a nat firewall and portmapping will be necessary.

I've got a Greandstream GXP-2000 working with several other phones, but reason for that is that I'm running my own Asterisk voip server.
This type Grandstream has port options which can be set to be used.
Greetings, Richard.
Spring naar forum:
Nieuw onderwerp Antwoorden
Gebruik BBcode of HTML om naar; 'Meerdere SIP endpoints (b.v. Zyxel, Grandstream)', te verwijzen!
Vergelijkbare onderwerpen
Onderwerp Forum         Laatste bericht
Zyxel P-2812HNU-F1 naar bridge mode? Eigen netwerk achter het Telfort modem : 2 17 apr 2016
Port forwarding zyxel p-2812hnu-f1 Eigen netwerk achter het Telfort modem : 2 13 jun 2013
NAT uitschakelen op zyxel p2812hnu-fx Eigen netwerk achter het Telfort modem : 1 29 mei 2013
Portforwarding Zyxel P-2812HNU-F1 Eigen netwerk achter het Telfort modem : 3 01 mei 2013
WRT320n i.c.m. ZyXel P-2812HNU Eigen netwerk achter het Telfort modem : 2 13 feb 2013